Maternal Warmth in Early Years Shapes Key Personality Traits and Future Success, Study Finds
Washington—Early childhood development and experiences of nurturing maternal care could have enduring effects on core personality characteristics, potentially shaping life achievements, including academic performance, financial prosperity, and overall quality of life, according to a study released by the American Psychological Association. The research indicates that effective parenting strategies and interventions might cultivate essential personality attributes, including openness to experience, conscientiousness, and agreeableness, highlighting the importance of attachment in child-parent relationships.
“These fundamental personality characteristics strongly influence crucial life outcomes, spanning from scholastic and professional achievements to physical and mental wellness,” explained Dr. Jasmin Wertz, the study’s principal investigator and psychology professor at the University of Edinburgh. “Our research indicates that cultivating supportive parenting environments during early child development could have a modest but meaningful and enduring influence on the development of these vital personality traits.”
Research Methodology: Twin Study Approach
Wertz and her research team investigated how maternal warmth during childhood—particularly between ages 5 and 10—correlated with the Big Five personality traits at age 18. Personality psychologists consider the Big Five traits as the fundamental dimensions of human personality: extraversion, agreeableness, openness, conscientiousness, and neuroticism, or emotional stability. This focus on maternal warmth and its impact on attachment and socioemotional development provides valuable insights into the role of parenting practices in shaping children’s personalities.
The study appeared in the journal American Psychologist.
The research team analyzed data from 2,232 British identical twins (51.1% female) monitored from birth through age 18 as participants in the Environmental Risk Longitudinal Twins Study. The study of identical twins enables researchers to account for genetic and environmental influences by comparing twins raised in the same household. Throughout the study, researchers conducted home visits, recording mothers discussing each of their children. Expert observers then evaluated the maternal behaviour for expressions of warmth and affection, focusing on maternal sensitivity and responsive caregiving.
Key Findings: Warmth Promotes Positive Personality Traits
Twins who experienced higher levels of maternal warmth during childhood demonstrated higher levels of openness, conscientiousness, and agreeableness in young adulthood. This finding highlights the importance of attachment and the mother-child relationship in shaping personality traits and socioemotional development. The study also suggests that reducing restrictive maternal control and promoting affectionate parenting techniques could contribute to better outcomes in early childhood development.
The findings suggest that positive, affectionate parenting interventions can influence key personality traits associated with future success, potentially creating intergenerational effects, according to Wertz. The researchers suggest that even small personality changes could yield significant societal benefits over time, especially in promoting conscientiousness, which strongly correlates with educational, professional, and health-related success. This underscores the importance of parenting interventions that focus on enhancing maternal warmth and reducing restrictive maternal control.
Limitations: Not All Personality Traits Are Equally Affected
The study found no significant long-term connections between maternal affection and either extraversion or neuroticism. These results indicate that other environmental or genetic elements—such as peer interactions, life events, and possibly later interventions—might have greater influence on these traits in adulthood. This highlights the complex interplay between parenting practices, attachment, and personality development.
The research emphasizes the importance of considering both genetic and environmental factors when developing parenting interventions intended to foster positive personality traits, Wertz noted. This approach aligns with the developmental approach to family health and underscores the need for comprehensive parenting education programs that enhance parenting knowledge and skills.
Implications for Parenting Interventions
“This study provides compelling evidence supporting the potential of parenting interventions to shape crucial aspects of personality development,” she concluded. “However, it also emphasizes the need for a sophisticated understanding of how various factors, including genetics, parenting styles, and life experiences, work together to form our individual personalities.”
Wertz emphasizes that these findings offer valuable practical implications for professionals working in education, family services, and mental health sectors. Since conscientiousness has been linked to academic and professional achievement, implementing parenting interventions that promote affectionate parenting and secure attachment could potentially enhance educational outcomes, psychological well-being, and social development on a broader societal level.
Evidence-Based Approaches to Support Parents
“We have numerous evidence-based approaches to support parents effectively, including policies that enhance family financial resources; accessibility to mental health services for maternal parents experiencing conditions like depression; and specialized programs designed to strengthen parent-child relationships,” she explained. These approaches can help address parenting stress and promote positive parenting practices, ultimately contributing to better cognitive and language development in children.
The study also highlights opportunities for developing targeted parental training frameworks to address disparities in personality development. “Through focusing on parenting practices that foster positive traits during childhood, we may be able to minimize the differences in life outcomes typically associated with socioeconomic status, family dynamics, and other environmental influences,” Wertz noted. This approach emphasizes the importance of parenting interventions that enhance maternal sensitivity and reduce restrictive maternal control.
The Broader Impact on Child Development
This research underscores the importance of early childhood development and the role of supportive parenting in shaping children’s socioemotional development and cognitive development. By promoting responsive caregiving and reducing restrictive maternal control, parenting interventions can potentially influence children’s long-term outcomes, including language development, motor development, and school readiness. These findings suggest that nurturing caregiving and maternal sensitivity play crucial roles in preventing behavior problems and promoting positive child behavioral outcomes.
The study’s findings also suggest that nurturing caregiving and maternal sensitivity play crucial roles in preventing behavior problems and promoting positive child behavioral outcomes. By enhancing parenting knowledge and skills through community-based interventions, it may be possible to improve children’s emotional understanding and overall development. This approach to parenting wellness could have far-reaching effects on child growth and development.
Future Research Directions
While the study focused primarily on maternal warmth and maternal behavior, future research could explore the impact of paternal involvement and different parenting styles on early childhood development. Additionally, investigating the effects of parenting interventions in low- and middle-income countries could provide valuable insights into the universality of these findings. Such research could further our understanding of how parent-child interactions and maternal investment influence child outcomes across diverse cultural contexts.
The Critical Role of Parenting Practices
This study highlights the critical role of parenting practices, particularly maternal warmth and responsive caregiving, in shaping children’s personality development and future outcomes. By implementing effective parenting strategies and promoting positive parenting techniques, we may enhance early childhood development and create lasting positive impacts on individuals and society. Future research could focus on the role of playful parenting and infant emotional development in strengthening attachment and overall child well-being, while also considering the impact of maternal education and maternal psychological well-being on parenting outcomes.
Source:
American Psychological Association (April 16, 2025). Nurturing now, thriving later: The lasting power of affectionate mothering. https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2025/04/power-affectionate-mothering. Accessed April 19, 2025
You may also like to read:
Understanding Selective Mutism: Beyond Typical Shyness
