Anxiety Beyond Words: How to Recognize, Understand, and Support Children with This Complex Communication Disorder
What is Selective Mutism?
Selective Mutism (SM) is a complex anxiety disorder that impacts a child’s capacity to speak in particular social environments, such as educational settings or community spaces. This condition is characterized by symptoms of anxiety that manifest specifically in speaking situations. Children with SM can communicate normally in comfortable settings, typically at home. Most children with SM have certain “comfort individuals” – usually family members like parents or siblings – with whom they can converse freely. However, when faced with unfamiliar people, children with SM experience anxiety-induced “freezing.” The condition often worsens when others step in to speak on behalf of the anxious child, inadvertently reinforcing their silent behavior by showing them that someone else will always communicate for them.
While selective mutism is most commonly observed in children, it’s important to note that selective mutism in adults can also occur, though it’s less frequently diagnosed. The prevalence of SM is estimated to be around 1% in children, with a slightly higher occurrence in multilingual populations.
What Does Selective Mutism Look Like?
Although selective mutism typically becomes apparent when children start school, the initial signs frequently emerge between ages 2 and 4. For a proper selective mutism diagnosis, symptoms must persist for a minimum of one month. If speaking difficulties only manifest during the initial month of schooling, this doesn’t qualify as selective mutism.
In social situations, children with SM might exhibit shy behavior, stay close to their “comfort person,” or communicate their responses by whispering into their trusted person’s ear instead of speaking directly to unfamiliar individuals. Some children with SM may resort to nonverbal communication methods, such as gesturing or head movements. However, certain children might be too anxious even for these non-verbal expressions. In severe cases, some children with selective mutism might be unable to communicate with teachers even in emergencies, such as when they’re injured.
Selective mutism frequently occurs in multilingual children, though it’s important to note that selective mutism isn’t caused by language barriers or discomfort with speaking different languages. Multilingual children might experience anxiety about others’ judgments regarding their accent or unique speech patterns. Furthermore, approximately 38% of children with SM also experience speech and language disorders, which can intensify their speaking anxieties.
Common Misunderstandings About Selective Mutism
Modern understanding shows that selective mutism isn’t a form of defiant behavior. Instead, these children experience anxiety about speaking with unfamiliar individuals. While mutism can be a symptom of post-traumatic stress, trauma-related mutism is distinguished by a sudden change in speaking patterns with previously familiar communication partners.
Additionally, while SM shares some characteristics with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), such as communication challenges, selective mutism symptoms stem from anxiety rather than communication difficulties. The key distinction is that children with SM can communicate effectively when comfortable, whereas those with ASD-related communication challenges may struggle with communication across all situations. It’s crucial to understand that autism and SM can coexist, but they are distinct conditions with different causes and treatment approaches.
Recommendations for Caregivers
When it comes to interventions for SM, caregivers play a crucial role. Here are some strategies to help children with selective mutism:
1.Foster courage! Since bravery is anxiety’s counterpart, developing “courage muscles” naturally diminishes anxious feelings. When your child displays courageous behavior, acknowledge it specifically by highlighting their exact actions, such as “I’m really impressed by how brave you’re being while exploring this unfamiliar playground!”
2. Demonstrate courage yourself! Engage with others during daily activities (like at restaurants or while shopping). Request assistance occasionally, even when unnecessary, to illustrate how interacting with others can be beneficial. When appropriate, let your child complete your sentences if you intentionally pause mid-question.
3. Rehearse new scenarios at home. This could range from practicing restaurant ordering (such as reviewing menus beforehand) to preparing for participation in sports activities or various classes. This can help reduce anxiety in social situations.
4. When visiting new environments, allocate 10-15 minutes for an “adjustment period.” This should encompass exploring the space and engaging in enjoyable activities with their “trusted person,” such as building with Legos or drawing pictures. This time should focus solely on becoming comfortable in the environment, without pressure to communicate, respond, greet others, or display formal manners.
5. Apply similar principles when introducing new people. Following their 10-15 minute “adjustment period,” incorporate the new person into the fun activity gradually! Avoid questioning or directing them. Concentrate on the activity itself (actively participating rather than merely observing) and offer specific praise for their accomplishments (such as “you’re showing amazing creativity with those toys,” “what an impressive castle you’ve built”). As caregivers, you may need to inform others not to expect immediate verbal interaction from your child.
6. Begin with straightforward choices where options are presented (like “would you prefer red or green?”). As confidence grows, progress to open-ended questions (such as “which color would you like?”). Always provide at least 5 seconds for response before repeating. If no response follows the second attempt, return to previously successful communication methods before trying again. Additional practice sessions away from the situation can also be beneficial.
7. Establish concrete bravery objectives with associated rewards! This might include collecting bravery stickers that can be exchanged for a toy after accumulating a specific number. Natural rewards also work well, such as earning ice cream by ordering it independently! It’s crucial that these rewards are exclusively given when goals are achieved.
Seeking Professional Help
Treatment for SM often involves a multidisciplinary approach. A comprehensive assessment by an interprofessional team, including a speech-language pathologist, can help determine the most effective selective mutism treatment plan. Treatment options include specialized approaches like Parent Child Interaction Therapy – Selective Mutism (PCIT-SM) and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). PCIT-SM emphasizes parent coaching, while CBT addresses thought patterns that contribute to anxiety and avoidance behaviors. Generally, CBT is recommended for older children who can better understand their thoughts and emotional responses.
Selective mutism therapy may also include speech therapy to address any co-occurring speech sound disorders or language development issues. A speech-language pathologist can work on improving expressive language, receptive language, and pragmatic language skills, which can boost the child’s confidence in communication.
Specialized programs like Mighty Mouth Camp have also demonstrated significant effectiveness in treatment! These programs often focus on functional communication in various social situations, helping children gradually overcome their anxiety about speaking.
For some children, anxiety medication may be considered as a supportive intervention to help reduce anxiety levels and facilitate participation in exposure-based activities. However, it’s important to note that medication should not be viewed as a standalone solution but rather as a complementary approach alongside behavioral interventions.
Early intervention is key in treating selective mutism. The earlier the condition is recognized and addressed, the better the outcomes tend to be. Parents who notice signs of selective mutism or have concerns about their child’s communication should seek a selective mutism test or evaluation from a qualified professional.
Additional Considerations
When addressing selective mutism, it’s important to consider various factors that may contribute to the condition:
• Family history: There may be a genetic component to selective mutism, as it often runs in families.
• Environmental factors: The child’s home environment and early experiences can influence the development of selective mutism.
• School performance: Selective mutism can impact a child’s academic progress, particularly in areas requiring verbal participation.
• Multilingual considerations: For children learning multiple languages, selective mutism may present differently and require specialized approaches.
Remember, if you’re wondering “why do I feel like I can’t talk sometimes,” it could be related to social anxiety or selective mutism. While the focus is often on selective mutism in children, adults can also experience similar challenges and may benefit from seeking professional help.
For additional resources and detailed information, please visit these authoritative websites:
• Child Mind Institute
• Kurtz Psychology
• ABCT
• Selective Mutism University (An e-learning website for parents, other caregivers, educators, and therapists): Selective Mutism University
Source:
Buhr, N. & Bater, L. (2024, November 25th). Beyond Typical Shyness… Understanding the Selectively Mute Child. Retrieved from https://infoaboutkids.org/blog/beyond-typical-shyness-understanding-the-selectively-mute-child.
You may also like to read:
80 Thoughtful Conversation Starters for Children
